Go-betweens needed to troubleshoot Pacific labour mobility schemes

Gemma/Flickr/CC BY-ND 2.0
Gemma/Flickr/CC BY-ND 2.0
Written by Richard Curtain

One of the successful features of New Zealand’s Recognised Seasonal Employer (RSE) scheme is its non-punitive approach to dealing with critical incidents involving employers and seasonal workers. The RSE does this through the use of regionally-based relationship managers. They are government employees who act as trusted intermediaries between all the main stakeholders. Their role is to work with both external and internal stakeholders to mediate and resolve problems.

Relationship managers are the first point of contact with employers who have a problem. They are responsible for assessing the situation and resolving the issue. The positions are in Immigration New Zealand, which is itself within the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE). The stated goal of MBIE is to “create a strong and high-performing economy without compromising the integrity of our environment and the safety of our workplaces”.

Relationship managers have solely an intermediary role. They are separate from the RSE operations unit, which administers the RSE and monitors compliance. The relationship managers are required to identify and manage risks by solving complex problems quickly and effectively. This involves managing potentially difficult relationships with employers and other relevant stakeholders, such as the liaison officers from the Pacific sending countries.

Relationship managers are also to work closely with other officers within their own Ministry (the MBIE) and with the Ministry of Social Development to foster an open, collaborative environment. They have a particular responsibility to provide “frank, open advice” to RSE employers on how to support their commitment to a ‘New Zealanders first’ approach and a commitment to “investment in people and skills” of their New Zealand workforce.

Immigration New Zealand asks RSE employers to contact their relationship manager as soon as possible to report any incident involving their seasonal workers [1]. These incidents can vary from a police matter involving a worker, a serious health issue, or a workplace dispute. The relationship manager then seeks to mediate a settlement between the employer and the Ministry officials that is good for the economy.

In 2018, of the five serious issues involving RSE employers notified to relationship managers, three were resolved in favour of the employer. This involved recommending a lesser penalty rather than removing the RSE employer’s registration. The assessment in favour of the RSE employer was based on the employer’s other commitments and the impact on the economy and the workers involved if the employer was suspended.

Nearly all of the 95 employers of RSE workers surveyed in 2018 (out of a total 135 employers) valued the work of the relationship managers. This response was evident in the RSE Employer Surveys in previous years as well, and was confirmed by interviews with RSE employers and two Pacific liaison officers.

Half of the RSE employers were satisfied and four out of ten very satisfied with the overall quality of service the RSE relationship managers provided. Nine out of ten RSE employers agreed or strongly agreed that their RSE relationship manager has a good understanding of their business.

Nine out of ten RSE employers also agreed that “my relationship manager responds to my enquiries within acceptable timeframes”, with half of the employers surveyed agreeing strongly with the statement. Similarly, 85 per cent of RSE employers agreed with the statement that “I received consistent information and advice from my relationship manager”, and of these, 45 per cent agreed strongly with the statement.

One quarter of RSE employers said that relationship managers were “helpful or give good advice or support”. Another 20 per cent said they “received good communication’ from their relationship manager, were in regular contact with them, or they were approachable. Over 20 per cent provided comments saying that their relationship manager provided prompt responses when asked for information, listens or understands their needs, or provides the answers they need.

The lesson for Australia is to work out how to set up a conflict resolution process that will give stability to new and existing Pacific work pathways. It is not a simple matter of setting up a similar role within government. In New Zealand, the MBIE is responsible for all the functions regarding Pacific work and residence pathways, which in Australia are covered by four separate agencies. Australia’s federal departmental silos ensure a strict demarcation between the four agencies involved in labour mobility: DFAT, Jobs and Small Business, Immigration (Home Affairs) and the Fair Work Ombudsman.

Australia needs relationship managers, but perhaps the best place to house them is the newly-founded Pacific Labour Facility (PLF), which has been outsourced to a private company (Palladium) by DFAT to facilitate Pacific labour mobility. For this to work, however, the PLF’s role as an independent intermediary would have to be accepted by all agencies involved.


Notes:

[1] Anne Hardie, 2017, ‘RSE one of the best in the World’, The Orchardist, 1 November.

image_pdfDownload pdf

Richard Curtain

Richard Curtain is a Research Fellow with the Development Policy Centre.

2 Comments

  • A timely and highly relevant topic Richard. Thank you again for bringing it to the fore. Australia needs to move openly and quickly to adopt its own pathway forward. The present system is inadequate given our size, unbalanced, reactive and unfair.

  • Nice article, Richard. The RSE Relationship Managers do a great job on the interface between the Pacifica Labour and Skills Team that George Rarere manages, the Regional Labour Governance Groups that monitor labour demands for labour in the different regions, the Labour Inspectorate that monitors compliance with workplace regulations and conditions of employment, the employers and the lead producer agencies like Apples and Pears New Zealand (formerly Pipfruit New Zealand), Horticulture New Zealand, New Zealand Winegrowers and New Zealand Kiwifruit Growers Inc.

    They are a vital cog in the system of relationships that sustain the dynamic RSE system that is currently under review as part of a wide-ranging reassessment of immigration policy in New Zealand, including New Zealand’s relations with Pacific countries (the “Pacific Reset” that the Minister of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Winston Peters announced early in 2018).

    The RSE Relationship Managers are one clear signal that Immigration New Zealand is not treating the RSE work policy as “business as usual” despite the fact that the policy is into its 12th year of operation. Maintaining a wider systems approach to the dynamic set of relationships that underpin a managed seasonal migration programme is essential if these programmes are to contribute to sustainable forms of economic and social development in both the labour sending and labour receiving countries.

Leave a Comment